Cicadae Periostracum (CP), derived from the slough of Cryptotympana atrata Fabricius, is a widely used insect-based medicinal material in traditional Chinese medicine. Due to the depletion of natural resources, artificial rearing has become prevalent; however, its impact on CP quality remains insufficiently elucidated. To evaluate this impact, along with that of host tree species and environmental factors, a comprehensive chromatographic strategy integrating UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS, UPLC-TQ-MS/MS and UPLC-DAD was developed for qualitative and quantitative analysis of N-acetyldopamine oligomers (NAOs), the active components in CP, as well as free/hydrolyzed amino acids (FAA/HAA). The extraction conditions for NAOs were optimized by response surface method. The results indicated that chemical profiles of CP obtained from wild collecting/artificial rearing, different host trees and regions exhibited a high degree of consistency. The artificial rearing CP samples showed higher levels of NAOs, FAA and HAA. Radar Plot Analysis showed that CP sourced from Malus pumila Mill (Mal) and Salix babylonica L. (Sal) achieved higher scores compared to five host trees studied. CP from Tengzhou region demonstrated relatively higher levels of NAOs and HAA. NAOs negatively correlated with annual near-surface air temperature, while HAA positively correlated with soil water content. These findings suggested that artificial rearing enhances CP quality, with Mal and Sal as promising host trees. Regions with lower annual near-surface air temperatures may promote NAOs accumulation. Overall, this research highlights the role of artificial rearing, host tree species and key environmental factors on the quality of CP and provides valuable insights for sustainable CP production and quality assessing.